Authorities Investigate Double Homicide Near Castle Rock State Park: Colter White and Sean Pfeffer Identified as Victims in Tragic Incident, Community in Shock
Boulder Creek, CA – Authorities have confirmed the identities of the two men found dead inside a pickup truck near Castle Rock State Park on March 24, 2025. The bodies were discovered by a passerby, prompting a swift investigation by the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office. The victims have been identified as Colter White, 54, of Boulder Creek, and Sean Pfeffer, 45, also of Boulder Creek. Investigators have announced that they are treating the deaths as a double homicide.
Details of Discovery:
The bodies of White and Pfeffer were found in a pickup truck parked in a secluded area near the state park, located in the rugged hills of the Santa Cruz Mountains. The discovery shocked the small community of Boulder Creek, where both men were known by friends and family. Authorities say they are pursuing all leads to determine the circumstances surrounding the deaths, though they have not yet disclosed how the men were killed.
Personal Connections and Tributes:
According to family members, Sean Pfeffer’s sister confirmed that the two men were best friends and had known each other for many years. Their close friendship, she said, had become a cornerstone of their lives, and the loss of both men is being deeply felt within the community. “They were inseparable,” she told Lookout News, expressing the pain of losing both loved ones in such a tragic manner.
Friends of Colter White and Sean Pfeffer have also paid tribute to the two men, describing them as hard-working, kind, and loyal individuals who always had a smile and a helping hand to offer. White, a long-time resident of Boulder Creek, was known for his friendly demeanor and commitment to the local community. Pfeffer, a beloved figure in the area, had a reputation for his warmth and willingness to support others in times of need.
Ongoing Investigation:
Investigators have not yet released a motive for the killings but have indicated that they are following several leads in their efforts to piece together what happened. The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office is working with the California Department of Justice and other local agencies to investigate the circumstances surrounding the double homicide.
Authorities have stated that they are examining surveillance footage from the area and speaking to anyone who might have information related to the victims’ last known activities. Investigators are also trying to determine if there was any connection between the two men’s deaths and the location where their bodies were found, which is often secluded and sparsely populated.
Community Reaction:
The discovery of the double homicide has left residents of Boulder Creek in shock and disbelief. The small mountain town, which is known for its tight-knit community, has expressed sadness and concern over the senseless violence that has now touched their lives. Locals have been vocal in their support for the families of White and Pfeffer, holding vigils and offering condolences.
“This kind of tragedy is something we never expected to happen here,” said Linda Martinez, a Boulder Creek resident. “We’re a small town, and we know each other. These men were part of our community, and it’s hard to believe they’re gone.”
The investigation has sparked a wave of fear and uncertainty in the area, with many questioning whether they are safe in their own homes and communities. While some have called for increased police presence, others have expressed confidence that local law enforcement will bring those responsible to justice.
Appeal for Information:
The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office is urging anyone with information related to the deaths of Colter White and Sean Pfeffer to come forward. They are asking for tips, no matter how small, that may help them solve the case.
Anyone who has information is asked to contact the Sheriff’s Office at (831) 471-1121 or Crime Stoppers at (831) 420-5995. Tips can also be submitted anonymously through the Crime Stoppers website.
Community’s Support for the Victims’ Families:
As the investigation continues, friends and family of the victims are struggling to come to terms with the loss of their loved ones. Colter White’s wife, Sandra White, described her husband as a devoted partner and loving father. “He was always there for our children and me,” she said tearfully. “He had a heart of gold, and we will miss him every day.”
Pfeffer’s sister also expressed the grief that has overtaken her family. “Sean was my rock. He was there for me through everything,” she said. “I don’t know how we’re going to move forward without him, but I know we have to keep his memory alive.”
The families of the two victims are now focusing on honoring their loved ones’ lives and seeking justice for their untimely deaths. A GoFundMe campaign has been set up to help cover funeral expenses for both men, and local community groups are organizing fundraising events to assist with the costs.
Looking Ahead:
While the community mourns the tragic loss of two beloved residents, the investigation remains a top priority for local law enforcement. Authorities have promised to continue working tirelessly until they can identify the individuals responsible for the deaths of Colter White and Sean Pfeffer and bring them to justice.
The investigation into this double homicide is ongoing, and the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office has vowed to leave no stone unturned as they search for answers. As the community of Boulder Creek waits for updates, their thoughts and prayers remain with the families of the victims, and they continue to hope for the swift resolution of the case
